Sunday, January 11, 2015

BB: Black and Blueberry Pie

Black and Blueberry PiePie. I could dig out the very dated quote from Mrs. Dull's "Southern Cooking" (1928), which was along the lines of "men love pie, and so we womenfolk need to please our men by baking them" but really, I love pie for myself, and don't need any excuse to bake one. This time the pie was younger niece's birthday celebration. It's so nice when the relatives are willing to accept upcoming baking assignments for their celebratory desserts!

The Black and Blueberry Pie the Alpha Bakers are blogging this week is simple and wonderful, and would be even more simple (though not so wonderful, even with my non-expert pastry skills), with a pre-bought pie crust. The recipe uses the same cream-cheese crust as the Luscious Apple Pie which I baked before the group got started. The dough was drier than I remembered in the mixing. I did add a bit more cream to the food processor before dumping the crumbly mix of flour, cream cheese, butter, etc. into a bag. It looked like a mess, but with enough pressing and pushing the crumbs became a mass that could be formed into two lumps for rolling out.

The dough chilled overnight, then the next day I rolled out the bottom crust, got it into the pan, and refrigerated it. I then rolled out the top and cut some berry-ish decorations, then slipped that crust onto a baking sheet and first into the freezer briefly, then the fridge to chill so the design wouldn't stretch when placed on the pie.

Black and Blueberry PieThen it was time for the very easy filling. The dry mixture (sugar and cornstarch, mostly) goes in a bowl, add lemon zest and juice are added to get a slurry. Dump in frozen blackberries and blueberries, stir, and turn the entire mix into the prepared crust. (Fresh berries are fine too, but it's winter in the northern hemisphere. Not getting good fresh berries right now...) On goes the top crust, after moistening the edge for a good seal. I had to let my top crust warm a bit before it could be tucked under and then crimped into a decorative edge. The pie then goes back to the fridge for another chill before baking.

Black and Blueberry PieThe pie bakes on a stone at the bottom of the oven, with a edge protector. Rose calls for a foil ring, but I used a silicone protector which I'd used on the apple pie as well as other recipes. However, when my pie was done my decorative crimped edge emerged from under the shield pretty much flat. It was also a little too brown, which is somewhat contradictory--if the silicone was too good an insulator and kept the heat from setting the crimped edge before it semi-melted, you'd have thought it would have kept things from getting too brown. But maybe not....Rose thought the silicone ring was the likely culprit, anyway. It caused some problems with the apple pie too, so I guess it needs to be chalked up as an unsuccessful experiment. Or maybe I can put it on after the pastry has set but before it started to really brown.

Black and Blueberry PieFlattened edge or no, the pie was a big hit, even with all the chocoholics next door. I served it with some barely sweetened whipped cream which gave just the right accent to the sweet berries and pastry. A la mode, with the pie warmed a bit, would also do well, but the birthday girl opted for whipped cream.

Black and Blueberry PieBlack and Blueberry PieBlack and Blueberry Pie

13 comments:

  1. My pie also leaked out like yours.. I used a metal foil ring.. and not silicon.and my pie rim crust also came out dark too.. Your pie looks great and i love that last pic with whipped cream on top.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It looks wonderful! Beautiful crust design. Whipped cream was a very good choice!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Maybe the silicon ring pressed on your rim design when you place it on and flattened it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was pretty careful to lay it down gently, and it's not heavy. OK, a little heavier than foil, I guess. But I think it's a temperature thing, and the pastry just melted a bit before it set.

      Delete
  4. I thought the ring goes on during the baking and not before? Like you bake it and if the edges are getting too dark THEN you place the ring to protect it? Regardless I loved you pie decor...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also love pie, and I remember when I was reading Lucinda Scala Quinn's MAD HUNGRY: FEEDING MEN AND BOYS (why gendered cookbooks, why?). There was a similar passage about how men are so all about pie, they love it more than birthday cake, etc... I silently passed the book to my boyfriend at the time, who read it and looked alarmed. 'She's wrong! YOU like pie. Men like CAKE!'

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your pie looks good! I used the silicone ring too and it did the same thing to my crimped edge but at least it didn't burn.

    ReplyDelete
  7. great looking pie! that Mrs. Dull quote sounds pretty funny now, doesn't it?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hands up everyone who made this just for their husband/spouse/significant other.
    Just as I thought.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My crust went flat too and I used a metal ring. The only thing I did differently was put the ring on before going in the oven. I usually wait till the crust is set and then add it if it's too brown. Not sure if that's the cause, but the crust tastes great either way. BTW, my husband will only eat apple pie...:( I love blackberry pie!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I loved the pie with cream too. Your crimping around the edge is so neat and uniform and the design so pretty. I think Mrs Dull would approve.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I love your pie! The picture with the whipped cream and the thick berry filling spilling out looks amazing...making me hungry for some pie :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think your finished pie looks very nice - the ring of berry juice looks like an artistic flourish of sorts. I have silicone and metal pie crust shields, but I can't say I've noticed any negative effects when using silicone, but I'll pay closer attention next time.

    Patricia @ ButterYum
    http://www.butteryum.org/roses-alpha-bakers/2014/12/21/tbb-black-and-blueberry-pie

    ReplyDelete